When it comes to building a competitive Diamond Dynasty squad in MLB The Show 25, flashy new cards often steal the spotlight. However, some veteran players—despite not being the shiniest options—deliver incredible value and performance. Whether you’re on a budget or just looking for underrated gems, these 10 veteran cards punch above their weight class.

1. Paul Goldschmidt (OVR 92 - 1B)

Goldschmidt remains one of the most consistent right-handed bats in the game. His high contact and power vs. lefties make him a nightmare for pitchers, and his defensive reliability at first base is a bonus. If you need a budget-friendly corner infielder, he’s a must-try.

2. Justin Verlander (OVR 91 - SP)

Even at 41 years old, Verlander’s pitch mix is elite. His fastball still has life, and his curveball remains one of the best in the game. For players looking to buy MLB The Show 25 stubs to upgrade their rotation, Verlander is a cheaper alternative who performs like a high-diamond arm.

3. Freddie Freeman (OVR 93 - 1B)

Freeman’s smooth swing and balanced stats make him a hit machine. He’s especially deadly against right-handed pitching, and his high vision ensures fewer strikeouts. If you’re debating where to invest, Freeman is a safe bet.

4. Zack Greinke (OVR 89 - SP)

Greinke might not throw gas anymore, but his pinpoint control and diverse arsenal keep hitters guessing. His slow curve and cutter combo is brutal on higher difficulties, making him a sneaky-good pickup.

5. Nelson Cruz (OVR 88 - DH)

Need pure power off the bench? Cruz’s 125 power vs. lefties is ridiculous for his rating. He’s a perfect pinch-hitter in tight spots and costs way less than most elite power bats.

6. Adam Wainwright (OVR 87 - SP)

Wainwright’s sinker-curveball combo is still effective, especially against players who struggle with off-speed pitches. He won’t dominate every game, but for his price, he’s a reliable back-end starter.

7. Joey Votto (OVR 90 - 1B)

Votto’s high discipline and clutch stats make him a tough out in key moments. His swing is also one of the smoothest for left-handed hitters, making him a great platoon option.

8. Miguel Cabrera (OVR 86 - 1B/3B)

While Miggy isn’t the MVP he once was, his bat-to-ball skills are still sharp. He’s a fun nostalgia pick who can hold his own against right-handed pitching.

9. Clayton Kershaw (OVR 92 - SP)

Kershaw’s declining velocity hasn’t stopped him from being effective. His slider and curveball remain among the best in the game, and his high control makes him a menace on Hall of Fame difficulty.

10. Robinson Canó (OVR 88 - 2B)

Cano’s swing has always played well in The Show, and this year is no exception. He’s a solid defender with great contact vs. righties, making him a viable middle-infield option early in the game’s cycle.

These veterans prove that you don’t always need the latest high-diamond cards to compete. Many of them can be acquired without spending a fortune, though if you’re in a hurry to buy MLB The Show 25 stubs, they’re worth the investment. Just remember—the best place to buy stubs MLB The Show 25 is always one that ensures safe and fair transactions, like trusted community sellers or verified platforms.